Presented by US Bank

News

Print
RSS

Monday Morning Mailbag

Posted Jul 23, 2012

Do you have a comment or question? Send it to the vikings.com Mailbag! Every Monday during the offseason we’ll post several comments and/or questions as part of the vikings.com Monday Morning Mailbag feature. Although we can’t post every comment or question, we will reply to every question submitted.

To submit a comment or question to the mailbag, send an email to Mike Wobschall at wobschallm@vikings.nfl.net. Remember to include your name and town on the email.

 

From your opinions I get a sense that you feel very positive about the youth and competition throughout the team. My question is what two positions (one offense, one defense) do you think will be the most competitive and won't have a starter decided until it comes down to the wire?
-- Hudson V.
Champaign, IL (originally Minneapolis, MN)

There’s no question that youth and competition are two aspects of this year’s training camp roster that standout to me, especially after the 9-23 record produced by an older Vikings roster the past two seasons. Vikings GM Rick Spielman, Head Coach Leslie Frazier and their staffs have done a nice job of blending veteran leadership with youth in their shaping of the roster to this point.

Two positions I see being ultra-competitive and not being decided until late in the preseason are at safety and the third running back spot. As a 1st-round pick, Harrison Smith is a strong candidate to emerge with a starting spot at safety. But who lines up next to him at the other safety spot is a question that may not be answered until the end of the preseason. At running back, Adrian Peterson and Toby Gerhart have the first and second positions locked up. After that, though, Frazier indicated earlier in the offseason that the team will be looking for an all-around back to fill out the depth chart, not just a scat back who would be used primarily in the passing game.

What will the Vikings strengths be on defense? Do you see the improved secondary being a strength? Or the defensive line that had 50 sacks last year? Or maybe the under-the-radar linebackers?
-- Chris L.

Without question the strength of last year’s Vikings defense was the defensive line, as they led the NFL in sacks and boasted the 2012 NFL sack king (Jared Allen – 22.0). I see the Vikings defensive line being even better overall in 2012, which means by definition it will be the strength of this year’s team.

With that being said, I also expect the Vikings secondary will make a significant step forward with the return of Chris Cook and Antoine Winfield on a regular basis and with the additions of Harrison Smith at safety and Zack Bowman, Chris Carr and Josh Robinson at cornerback.

I noticed the NY Jets will not be re-signing S Jim Leonhard, probably because he has displayed durability issues over the last two seasons. Given our struggles in the secondary and especially at the safety position, do you think it would be wise to sign him? If nothing else, to at least heat up competition for the starting job?
-- Jamie
Minneapolis, MN

It’s never a bad idea to add a talented player to the roster and/or to beef up the competition at a position. Leonhard is certainly a talented player, and his veteran presence would help any team. I’m not sure if the Vikings are a good fit for him or not. There is already expected to be a spirited competition for playing time at safety, and that competition will feature young players such as rookies Robert Blanton and Harrison Smith, second-year player Mistral Raymond and Jamarca Sanford. At this point, I think the Vikings may be better off letting those youngsters compete for time and develop, rather than bringing in a veteran player who is 29 and is trying to come back from a torn patellar tendon.

In an interview I saw of Josh Robinson, he said that he will do anything to make the team, even if it's playing on special teams. That being said, do you think the Vikings will try him out as a return specialist this preseason?
-- Jon
Blaine, MN

I anticipate Special Team s Coordinator Mike Priefer incorporating Robinson into the mix at either or both the kickoff and punt return roles. Robinson’s speed is unquestioned – he was the fastest player at this year’s Combine – and he showed me tremendous burst and suddenness during his time working in the Vikings offseason program. Suffice it to say, Robinson possesses the physical traits you want out of a kick/punt returner. In addition, Robinson also has experience returning punts in college, averaging 15.2 yards per return as a sophomore at the University of Central Florida.

I love RB Toby Gerhart's work ethic. He played well when in for Adrian Peterson last year. Now, do you see him as a goal line/ third-down back, or an every-down back?
-- Matt
Seattle, WA

I see Gerhart as an every-down back in the NFL. In fact, I think he'd be a starter on many teams in the NFL. In Minnesota, though, he’s playing behind the best running back in the NFL, so it’s hard for him to see much action when Peterson is healthy. I do believe Peterson will return to the lineup healthy early in the season – perhaps as early as Week 1 – but even so I also believe the Vikings will find a way to use Gerhart more frequently. To use Gerhart as just a third-down or goal-line back would a waste of his talents, in my opinion.

Latest Video

Featured Photo Gallery

Latest Audio